Pandemic-era shortages broke the familiar lease-return cycle for years. Now Penske Automotive says it's finally refilling, and the dealers paying attention are about to get two wins for the price of one.
Toyota lease maturities at Penske are projected to rise from 4,200 this year to 5,600 next year, while BMW returns climb from 9,500 to 10,700. Industrywide, Cox Automotive expects 3 million lease maturities in 2026 and 4.3 million in 2027.
With residual values less favorable than they were during the shortage years, more of these vehicles are actually making it back into dealer inventory instead of getting bought out early.
We still have upside with the lease penetration.
Want the full conversation?
🎙️ Listen to today's Automotive State of the Union episode for the complete discussion.
The Same Customer, Twice, If You're Paying Attention
A lease return isn't just a used car showing up on your lot, it's a customer who's about to make a decision, and right now nobody's guaranteed to make it with you.
Penske's Q2 lease penetration sat at 32%, ten points above the roughly 22% industry average, and the pattern behind that gap is simple: get familiar with the customer lifecycle again, and start the conversation before the lease matures, not after the vehicle's already back at auction.
What Every Dealer Should Be Doing Right Now
Know your own maturity numbers. If you don't know how many leases are coming due in your own database over the next 12 months, that's the first gap to close, not the lease-end conversation itself.
Reach out before the notice does. The manufacturer's own lease-end letter is not a marketing opportunity you want to lose to. Whoever talks to the customer first about their options usually keeps them.
Treat the returned vehicle like real inventory, not a formality. These units carry better residuals than the pandemic-era bargains dealers got used to, which means letting one slip to the auction lane is a bigger loss than it used to be.
This scales with the brand mix you carry. Premium brands run lease penetration in the mid-40% range industry-wide. If that's your store, the upside here is even bigger than the topline numbers suggest.
So who actually owns this customer when the lease comes due, you or the auction lane?
Right now, for a lot of stores, the honest answer is neither; the customer just goes wherever the next convenient option shows up. The dealers who build a real pre-maturity outreach process this year are the ones who turn that coin flip into a retained customer and a solid piece of used inventory at the same time.
